Witches Brew

Price range: $9.95 through $24.95

Something’s bubbling in the cauldron… and it smells like chocolate oranges.

Witches Brew is our October favorite, built on smooth, naturally sweet rooibos with bright orange peel, crunchy cacao nibs, and a soft swirl of vanilla. It tastes like orange vanilla wrapped in a warm blanket. Bold and flavorful.

And it’s completely caffeine free, so you can sip it at midnight on Halloween (or any spooky night) without staying up until sunrise. Pour a mug while the kids sort their candy haul, curl up for a scary movie, or bring a thermos to the neighborhood Halloween party.

No spells required. Just hot water and a few minutes of patience.